Problem 1
What is the shared research question in this example?
Show worked solution
How the plant-care notebook helps the helpers.
ela-2017:W.K.2ela-2017:W.K.7ela-2017:W.K.8ela-2026:W.K.2ela-2026:W.K.7
ela-2017:W.K.2 Use a combination of drawing, dictating, and writing to compose informative/explanatory texts that name what is being written about and supply some information about the topic.
ela-2017:W.K.7 Participate in shared research and writing projects (e.g., explore a number of books by a favorite author and express opinions about them).
ela-2017:W.K.8 With guidance and support from adults, recall information from experiences or gather information from provided sources to answer a question.
ela-2026:W.K.2 Use drawing, dictation, and/or writing to compose informative or explanatory pieces about a given topic.
ela-2026:W.K.7 With adult support, recall information from experiences or gather information from provided sources to answer a question.
Learning goal: Participate in shared research, recall or gather information from supplied sources, and compose an information page that names a topic and supplies accurate information. Children may draw, dictate and write in combination. The task requires an actual composed page and participation in the shared inquiry, not only answering a question about a finished example.
Choose a narrow class question: “How does the example plant-care notebook help the helpers?” Use A Seedling’s Care and Helpers at the Plant Shelf from the information-reading lesson. Read them aloud again so the source is available to every learner. A child may also recall the class’s actual use of a care record, but distinguish a personal observation from a detail in the example texts.
Gather facts that answer the question. The sources say a helper records a date and what was checked, another helper reads before the next job, and records help people share accurate information. These details fit the question. The color of a notebook cover, if not stated, should not be invented or treated as essential research evidence.
Create a shared class chart with two columns: information and where it came from. Adults can write while children dictate, point to a source or draw a symbol for it. Formal citation style is not expected, but the chart should distinguish the two texts and any real class observation. A shared research project includes children contributing questions, evidence or organization, rather than watching the adult do all the thinking.
Plan an individual information page. Name the topic clearly—such as the plant-care notebook—and supply at least one accurate detail. A drawing can show a dated entry and two helpers using it. Dictate or write a sentence that explains the picture: “A helper reads the record before the next job.” The written claim and the illustration should agree.
An information page differs from an opinion page. “I like the notebook” is a preference; “The notebook records what was checked” supplies information from the source. Both kinds of writing can be useful, but this task asks for explanation. If a child wants to add a personal opinion, label it separately so it does not replace the required accurate information.
Worked example 1: Relevant evidence. The research question asks how the record helps helpers. Select the detail that another helper reads it before doing the next job. A decorative picture of a flower does not answer the question without further explanation.
Worked example 2: Compose a page. Title: “Our Example Care Record.” Drawing: a dated entry beside a plant. Dictated sentence: “The record shows what a helper checked.” Verify that the title names the topic and the sentence supplies a source-supported detail. The title alone is not a complete information piece.
Worked example 3: Repair an invented fact. A draft says every plant needs water three times a day. Neither source supports that, and the texts explain that plants differ. Revise to the supported instruction to check soil before adding water and use appropriate adult guidance.
Guided research project: Agree on the shared question, read the sources, gather contributions on the class chart and discuss which details answer it. Invite children to ask what a detail means and to identify its source. Keep the chart available while they compose individual pages.
Independent evidence with adult support: Create an information page naming its topic and giving accurate information through drawing, dictation and writing. Explain where one fact came from and describe one contribution to the shared project. Repeat with another question based on familiar experiences or provided sources.
Rubric: Award one point each for a named topic, accurate relevant information, an illustration or sentence that communicates it, and participation in gathering or recalling evidence. Record prompting and transcription help. If a child copies unrelated text, narrow the question and ask which words answer it. Extend by combining several reviewed pages into a class information book with contributors credited truthfully.
An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.
What is the shared research question in this example?
How the plant-care notebook helps the helpers.
Name a relevant detail from the supplied texts.
Another helper reads the record before the next job, or the record shows what was checked.
The title “Our Example Care Record” names the topic. What fact could you add so the page tells how the notebook helps?
The title names the topic but does not yet tell how the notebook helps. Add a source-supported fact, such as “The record shows what a helper checked.”
How does “I like the notebook” differ from the required explanation?
It expresses a preference; the task also needs source-supported information about what the notebook does.
What should happen to an unsupported claim about watering every plant three times daily?
Remove or revise it using the actual sources, which explain that plants differ and soil should be checked.
Produce a source-supported information page and describe your research contribution.
Performance rubric: topic, accurate relevant detail, clear communication and participation; one point each with support recorded. Sample: the title “Our Example Care Record”, a drawing of a dated notebook page beside a plant, and the dictated sentence “Another helper reads the record before the next job.” The child says, “I found that in Helpers at the Plant Shelf.”