High school · Social studiesAbout 120 minutes
Social studiesHigh schoolAbout 120 minutes

Explain how individuals can participate through non-governmental organizations to help address humanitarian needs

Instruction on humanitarian needs, NGOs and principles, forms of participation and evaluation, three worked examples, an NGO profile and a participation proposal.

Ohio learning standards this draft targets

ss-2018:CONTEMPORARY_WORLD_ISSUES:7

Read the standard text

ss-2018:CONTEMPORARY_WORLD_ISSUES:7 Individuals can participate through non-governmental organizations to help address humanitarian needs.

Provisional targets. Clause-by-clause educational review is still pending.

Section 1 · LearnLearn the idea
Five dated events: the International Committee of the Red Cross founded in Geneva (1863), the American Red Cross founded by Clara Barton (1881), the Oxford Committee for Famine Relief, later Oxfam, formed (1942), Medecins Sans Frontieres founded in France (1971), and its Nobel Peace Prize (1999). They show private humanitarian organizations, the ICRC among them with a special status under the Geneva Conventions, taking on humanitarian needs across more than a century.Five dated events: the International Committee of the Red Cross founded in Geneva (1863), the American Red Cross founded by Clara Barton (1881), the Oxford Committee for Famine Relief, later Oxfam, formed (1942), Medecins Sans Frontieres founded in France (1971), and its Nobel Peace Prize (1999). They show private humanitarian organizations, the ICRC among them with a special status under the Geneva Conventions, taking on humanitarian needs across more than a century.Humanitarian organizations: selected dates1863International Committee of the Red Cross founded,Geneva1881American Red Cross founded by Clara Barton1942Oxford Committee for Famine Relief (Oxfam) formed1971Medecins Sans Frontieres founded in France1999Medecins Sans Frontieres awarded the Nobel PeacePrize
Five dated events: the International Committee of the Red Cross founded in Geneva (1863), the American Red Cross founded by Clara Barton (1881), the Oxford Committee for Famine Relief, later Oxfam, formed (1942), Medecins Sans Frontieres founded in France (1971), and its Nobel Peace Prize (1999). They show private humanitarian organizations, the ICRC among them with a special status under the Geneva Conventions, taking on humanitarian needs across more than a century.

Learning goal: Explain what non-governmental organizations are and how they address humanitarian needs, describe the ways individuals can participate through them, and evaluate an organization and a form of participation so that help actually meets the need.

Humanitarian needs. A humanitarian need is a need for the basics of survival and dignity: food, clean water, shelter, medical care, sanitation and protection from violence. Humanitarian needs arise suddenly in disasters such as earthquakes, floods and epidemics, and more slowly in famines and long wars that drive people from their homes. Refugees, who have crossed an international border to escape persecution or war, and internally displaced people, who have fled but remain inside their own country, are among those with the greatest needs. Humanitarian aid aims to save lives and relieve suffering now; development work aims to reduce poverty and vulnerability over years. Many organizations do both, and it helps to know which one a particular appeal is for.

Non-governmental organizations. A non-governmental organization, or NGO, is a private, non-profit body that is independent of government, although it may receive government grants. NGOs range from large international organizations with staff in dozens of countries to a single congregation's relief committee. Some humanitarian organizations have long histories. The International Committee of the Red Cross was founded in Geneva in 1863 after Henry Dunant witnessed the wounded left untreated following the battle of Solferino in 1859; the American Red Cross was founded by Clara Barton in 1881. The ICRC is a special case: it is a private Swiss association, but the Geneva Conventions give it a mandate and governments treat it as having its own international legal status, so it describes itself as distinct from ordinary NGOs. Oxfam and Doctors Without Borders, below, are straightforward NGOs. The Oxford Committee for Famine Relief, later Oxfam, began in England in 1942. Médecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) was founded in France in 1971 and received the Nobel Peace Prize in 1999. These organizations exist because governments cannot or will not meet every need: a government may be overwhelmed, may lack access, or may itself be a party to a conflict.

Humanitarian principles. Many humanitarian NGOs commit to four principles. Humanity: suffering is to be relieved wherever it is found. Impartiality: aid goes according to need alone, without discrimination by nationality, religion, race or politics. Neutrality: the organization takes no side in a conflict. Independence: it acts on its own judgment, not as an instrument of any government's aims. These principles are how organizations gain access to people on all sides of a war; knowing them also helps an individual judge whether an organization is humanitarian or has another purpose.

How individuals participate. The standard says individuals can participate through NGOs. There are several ways, and they are not equally useful in every situation.
- Giving money. Relief organizations commonly say that cash is the most flexible gift, because it lets them buy what is needed near the disaster, which is faster and supports the local economy. Donated goods such as used clothing often do not match the need and must be shipped, sorted and stored, which costs money and can block supply routes.
- Volunteering. Local NGOs, food banks, refugee-resettlement agencies and chapters of national organizations take volunteers for sorting, tutoring, driving, blood drives and disaster training. Overseas disaster zones usually need trained professionals rather than untrained volunteers, and unplanned arrivals can burden the response.
- Giving skills. Doctors, engineers, translators and accountants can volunteer professional skills through organizations that can use them.
- Advocacy. Individuals can urge governments to fund aid, to admit refugees or to protect aid workers, and can join NGO campaigns that do this.
- Raising awareness and funds. Students can organize fundraisers for an established NGO, which combines awareness with giving.

Evaluating an organization. Before participating, an individual should check that the organization is real and uses resources well. In the United States a charity's tax-exempt status can be checked with the Internal Revenue Service, and larger charities file annual public reports showing their spending. Ask: what need does it address and where; does it work with local partners who know the community; does it report results; does it follow humanitarian principles? A new, unknown group that appears only after a disaster, asks for payment in unusual forms or cannot say where money goes should not be trusted until checked.

A fully worked model. A hypothetical Ohio high school learns of a severe earthquake abroad and wants to help. A first idea is a clothing drive. Evaluate it: the need reported by relief agencies is for shelter, water and medical care; clothing would need to be shipped overseas, sorted and matched to sizes and climate; the cost of shipping may exceed the value of the clothes. Revise: the students hold a fundraiser and send the money to an established NGO already working in the affected region, after checking its tax-exempt status and published reports. They also contact a local refugee-resettlement agency, which says that families from the region arriving in Ohio need tutors in English; ten students sign up for training. Assess: the money reaches an organization with staff on the ground; the tutoring meets a local humanitarian need through a second NGO. The students chose participation that matched the need rather than the one that felt most tangible. The school, earthquake and numbers are hypothetical.

The misconception. Students often believe that any help is good help, and that sending things is better than sending money because it feels more personal. Help that does not match the need can cost more than it gives. Effective participation starts from the need, works through an organization equipped to meet it, and checks that organization first.

Section 2 · ModelWork through the examples

Worked example 1 — match participation to need: After a hypothetical flood in an Ohio river town, a regional food bank asks for volunteers to sort donated food and for cash to buy water. A student with a free Saturday volunteers to sort; a family that cannot volunteer donates money. Both match stated needs. A third person drives a truckload of unrequested furniture to the town; with no place to store it, it blocks a parking lot needed for relief vehicles. The first two participated through an NGO according to its request; the third acted outside any organization and added to the burden.

Worked example 2 — apply the principles: A hypothetical organization says it delivers food only to villages that support one side in a civil war. Test it: it fails impartiality (aid by need, not politics) and neutrality (no side in conflict). It may still be a real organization, but it is not acting as a humanitarian one, and its presence could put neutral aid workers at risk if the sides stop trusting them. An individual choosing where to give should prefer an organization that follows the principles.

Worked example 3 — check an organization: A student sees a social-media appeal from a group formed yesterday asking for gift cards for disaster victims. Checklist: no record of tax-exempt status; no annual report; payment in gift cards, which are hard to trace; no named local partner. Conclusion: do not give until verified; instead give to an established NGO whose status and spending can be checked. The student is not assuming fraud; the student is declining to give without evidence.

Section 3 · DoPractice, demonstrate, and explain

NGO profile record: Research one humanitarian NGO that works internationally and one that works in your area of Ohio. For each, record from its own reports and an independent source: founding date, the humanitarian needs it addresses, where it works, whether it states the four humanitarian principles, how an individual can participate (money, volunteering, skills, advocacy) and one way you checked its legitimacy.

Independent performance: Write a one-page participation proposal for a real or hypothetical humanitarian need. Success criteria: you describe the need precisely (what, where, for whom) from a source; you choose an NGO and justify it with at least two evaluation checks; you choose a form of participation and explain why it matches the need better than an alternative you considered; you name one risk of well-meant but mismatched help; and you state how you would assess whether your participation helped.

Supervised participation (with teacher and family approval): Carry out one small activity that an NGO has asked for, such as preparing materials it has requested, joining an approved volunteer task, or helping with a supervised collection of items the NGO says it needs. Giving money is never required. Afterward, write a short reflection: what you did, how it matched what the NGO said it needed, and what you would change.

Section 4 · Check7-question lesson practice test

An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.

Problem 1

What is a non-governmental organization, and why do humanitarian NGOs exist alongside governments?

Show worked solution

An NGO is a private, non-profit body independent of government, though it may accept government grants. Humanitarian NGOs exist because governments may be overwhelmed by a disaster, lack access to affected people, or be parties to a conflict, so an independent organization can reach needs a government cannot or will not meet.

Problem 2

Define a humanitarian need and distinguish humanitarian aid from development work.

Show worked solution

A humanitarian need is a need for the basics of survival and dignity: food, water, shelter, medical care, sanitation and protection. Humanitarian aid aims to save lives and relieve suffering now, after a disaster or during a conflict; development work aims to reduce poverty and vulnerability over years. Knowing which an appeal is for helps an individual judge how the money will be used.

Problem 3

Name the four humanitarian principles and explain why neutrality matters in a war zone.

Show worked solution

Humanity, impartiality, neutrality and independence. Neutrality means taking no side, which is how an organization gains the trust of all parties and therefore access to people on every side. An organization seen as partisan may be refused entry or attacked, which harms the people it meant to help.

Problem 4

Why do relief organizations commonly prefer cash to donated goods after a disaster abroad?

Show worked solution

Cash is flexible: the organization buys what is actually needed, often near the disaster, which is faster and supports local businesses. Donated goods may not match the need and must be shipped, sorted and stored, which costs money and can clog supply routes needed for relief.

Problem 5

List four ways an individual can participate through NGOs and give a situation where each fits.

Show worked solution

Giving money, for an overseas disaster where local purchasing is fastest; volunteering, at a local food bank or resettlement agency; giving professional skills, such as a doctor serving with a medical NGO; and advocacy, urging government to fund aid or protect aid workers. Each fits a different need and a different person's resources.

Problem 6

What checks should an individual make before giving to an organization that appeared after a disaster?

Show worked solution

Check its tax-exempt status with the IRS, look for public reports of spending, ask what need it addresses and with which local partners, and be wary of untraceable payment forms such as gift cards. Declining to give until these are confirmed is not an accusation; it is requiring evidence that the help will arrive.

Problem 7

In the hypothetical school model, why was the clothing drive replaced, and what does that show about effective participation?

Show worked solution

The reported need was shelter, water and medical care, and shipping and sorting clothing could cost more than it was worth. The students instead sent money to an established NGO already working there and tutored arriving families through a local agency. Effective participation starts from the need and uses organizations equipped to meet it.