Predict periodic trends from electron configuration and position on the table
Several sessions: a safe investigation, modeled examples, independent calculation practice and a written explanation. Atomic masses are used to two decimal places; every investigation uses household or teacher-supplied dilute materials, goggles, and no open flame without a supervising adult.
Ohio learning standards this draft targets
science-2018:C.PM.2science-2018:C.PM.1
Read the standard text
science-2018:C.PM.2 Periodic Table
science-2018:C.PM.1 Atomic structure
Provisional targets. Clause-by-clause educational review is still pending.
📘Section 1 · LearnLearn the idea
First ionization energies of the period 3 elements, rounded to the nearest kJ/mol: sodium 496, magnesium 738, aluminum 578, silicon 787, phosphorus 1012, sulfur 1000, chlorine 1251 and argon 1521. The overall rise from 496 to 1521 across the period reflects the growing effective nuclear charge on level 3; the two small dips, at aluminum (first 3p electron) and sulfur (first paired 3p electron), are real features of the data, not errors. Values are reference data from standard tables and are not measured in this lesson.
Learning goal: Read an element's electron configuration from its position on the periodic table, explain why elements in one group share properties, and use atomic structure to explain and predict trends in atomic radius, ionic radius, first ionization energy, electronegativity and room-temperature state across a period and down a group.
The table is a configuration chart. Physical Science introduced the periodic table as elements in order of increasing atomic number, arranged so that elements with similar properties fall in the same column, with groups (columns), periods (rows), and the regions of metals, nonmetals and metalloids. This course adds the reason the arrangement works. Each period begins a new energy level. The first two columns are the s-block, where the s sublevel of the outer level fills; the six columns on the right are the p-block, where the p sublevel fills (helium, placed with the noble gases for its behavior, is really 1s² and belongs to the s-block); the ten middle columns are the d-block, the transition elements. So the position of an element tells you its configuration: the period number gives the level of the valence electrons, the block gives the sublevel, and the column within the block gives how many electrons are in it. Sulfur sits in period 3, in the fourth column of the p-block, so it is [Ne]3s²3p⁴.
Why groups share properties. Reading down any column, the valence configuration repeats: every group 1 element is ns¹, every group 2 element ns², every halogen ns²np⁵, every noble gas ns²np⁶ (helium, 1s², is the exception in count but not in behavior, since its only level is full). Valence electrons are responsible for most chemical properties, so elements with the same valence configuration react in the same way: all the alkali metals lose one electron and form 1+ ions, all the halogens gain one electron and form 1− ions. The properties repeat because the configurations repeat; that repetition is what periodic means.
Two ideas explain the trends. Almost every trend in this lesson follows from two competing effects. First, nuclear charge: more protons pull each electron more strongly. Second, shielding: inner electrons sit between the nucleus and the outer electrons and cancel part of the nuclear pull, so an outer electron feels an effective charge smaller than the full nuclear charge. Across a period, protons are added one at a time while the new electrons go into the same outer level, which shields poorly; the effective pull on the outer electrons rises. Down a group, each step adds a whole new level, so the outer electron is both farther from the nucleus and shielded by one more filled shell; the added protons are largely canceled.
Atomic radius. Atomic radius is half the distance between the nuclei of two bonded atoms of the same element. Across a period of main-group elements, radius decreases: the growing effective charge pulls the same outer level in tighter, so chlorine is smaller than sodium even though it has more electrons. Down a group, radius increases: each new level is farther out, so potassium is larger than sodium. Students often assume more electrons means a bigger atom; across a period that is exactly backwards, because the added electrons enter the same level while the nucleus gains pull. Across the transition metals the decrease is small and irregular, because the added electrons go into an inner d sublevel.
Ionic radius. A cation is smaller than its parent atom: sodium loses its entire third level, so Na⁺ is only the neon-like core and is much smaller than Na. An anion is larger than its parent: adding an electron to chlorine increases repulsion among the outer electrons while the nuclear charge stays the same, so Cl⁻ is larger than Cl. Down a group, ions grow for the same reason atoms do. Comparing an ion with its atom is the common mistake; always ask whether a level was removed or whether repulsion was added.
First ionization energy. The first ionization energy is the energy needed to remove the most loosely held electron from a gaseous atom in its ground state. Among main-group elements it rises across a period, because the outer electrons are held more tightly by a larger effective charge, and it falls down a group, because the outer electron is farther away and better shielded. The general trend has small exceptions: in period 3 the value dips slightly at aluminum, whose outer electron is the first in a 3p orbital, higher in energy than the 3s, and again at sulfur, where the fourth 3p electron is the first to pair up and is pushed out by repulsion. The diagram shows the period 3 values. Second and later ionization energies are reserved for later study, but the pattern is easy to see: removing a second electron from sodium would break into the filled core and costs far more.
Electronegativity. Electronegativity measures how strongly an atom in a bond attracts the shared electrons. On the common scale fluorine is highest at 3.98 and the values fall to the left and downward: chlorine 3.16, oxygen 3.44, nitrogen 3.04, carbon 2.55, hydrogen 2.20, sodium 0.93, potassium 0.82. The trend follows from the same two effects: a small atom with a high effective charge pulls bonding electrons hard. Noble gases are usually left off the scale because they rarely form bonds. Electronegativity difference is the tool that predicts bond type in the next lesson.
Electron affinity, briefly. Electron affinity is the energy change when a gaseous atom gains an electron. Halogens release the most energy on gaining an electron, because the added electron completes the outer p sublevel, giving a noble-gas configuration, under a strong effective charge; the trend is roughly the mirror of ionization energy but is less regular, and it is treated qualitatively here.
State at room temperature. Whether an element is a solid or a gas at room temperature depends on how strongly its particles attract one another. Metals are held in a lattice by delocalized electrons and are solids, with mercury the familiar exception. The nonmetals on the right exist as single atoms (the noble gases) or small molecules held by weak attractions: nitrogen, oxygen, fluorine, chlorine and the noble gases are gases; bromine is a liquid; iodine is a solid because its larger molecules attract one another more. Carbon and silicon form giant covalent networks and are hard high-melting solids. Position therefore predicts state, but through bonding and intermolecular attraction, not directly.
Metals, nonmetals, metalloids. Metals lose electrons easily (low ionization energy, low electronegativity), conduct, and are malleable. Nonmetals gain or share electrons (high electronegativity) and are poor conductors. Metalloids along the staircase, boron, silicon, germanium, arsenic, antimony and tellurium, behave in between: silicon looks metallic and conducts a little, but is brittle and bonds like a nonmetal. To judge whether a metalloid will act as a metal or a nonmetal in a given situation, ask what the situation demands: for electron sharing in a solid network, silicon acts as a nonmetal; for electrical conduction under controlled conditions, it can be made to behave enough like a metal to be useful.
A worked prediction. Compare sodium and chlorine, both period 3. Sodium is [Ne]3s¹; chlorine is [Ne]3s²3p⁵. Chlorine has six more protons acting on the same level, so it is smaller, has the higher first ionization energy (1251 kJ/mol against 496) and the higher electronegativity (3.16 against 0.93). Now compare chlorine with bromine, directly below it: bromine's valence electrons are in level 4, farther out and behind one more shell, so bromine is larger, more easily ionized and less electronegative (2.96). Every comparison uses the same two questions: which atom has the outer electrons in a higher level, and which has the larger effective charge on the same level.
Where the rest of the standards is taught. C.PM.1 is shared with the atomic models lesson, which teaches how the atomic model changed with evidence, spectra and orbital diagrams; this lesson uses configurations to explain the periodic table.
Investigation: rank conductors and find them on the table. Materials: a battery-powered continuity tester or a simple circuit with a 3 V cell, a bulb or buzzer and two clip leads; and small samples in two sets. Set 1, elements: copper wire, aluminum foil, a graphite rod (carbon) and, if the teacher has them, a piece of silicon and a lump of sulfur. Set 2, materials that are not single elements: a steel nail (an alloy, mostly iron), a zinc-coated washer (zinc over steel), a pencil core (graphite mixed with clay), a plastic rod and a chalk stick (both compounds). Steps: touch both leads to each sample, record whether the bulb is bright, dim or dark, and repeat twice; then mark only the Set 1 elements on a blank periodic table with their results, and list the Set 2 materials separately with what each is made of, because the conductivity of an alloy, a mixture or a compound cannot be assigned to one element's position. A result that supports the claim: among the elements, the bright conductors sit on the left and center of the table (metals) and sulfur, on the right, is dark (a nonmetal), with graphite, a form of the nonmetal carbon, as the exception that conducts; steel conducts because it is mostly the metal iron, while plastic and chalk do not. Silicon may not light the bulb at all: pure silicon conducts so weakly that a dark bulb is inconclusive, not proof that it is an insulator. What the model cannot show: a bulb test ranks only coarsely, cannot distinguish two good metals, and a dark bulb may mean an oxide coating or a poor contact rather than a nonconductor; test the circuit on copper first and clean surfaces before recording.
Reserved for later. Additional ionization energies, quantitative electron affinities, and the properties of the transition, lanthanide and actinide elements are beyond this course.
✏️Section 2 · ModelWork through the examples
Worked example 1 — configuration from position. An element is in period 3, group 2. Period 3 puts its valence electrons in level 3; group 2 is the second column of the s-block, so 3s². The element is [Ne]3s², magnesium, atomic number 12. Its neighbor to the right, aluminum, adds one electron to a new sublevel: [Ne]3s²3p¹. Reading position to configuration is exact for the first three periods and needs no memorization of atomic numbers.
Worked example 2 — which is larger, which is more easily ionized. Compare magnesium and calcium. Both are ns²; calcium's outer electrons are in level 4, magnesium's in level 3. Calcium is larger, because level 4 lies farther out and is shielded by one more filled shell; for the same reason calcium's outer electrons are held less tightly and its first ionization energy is lower. Now compare magnesium with phosphorus in the same period: phosphorus has three more protons pulling on level 3, so phosphorus is smaller and has the higher ionization energy (1012 kJ/mol against 738). The justification in every case names the level and the effective charge.
Worked example 3 — ionic radius. Order Cl, Cl⁻ and K⁺ by size. Cl⁻ is larger than Cl: the same 17 protons must now hold 18 electrons, and extra repulsion in the outer level spreads it out. K⁺ has 18 electrons too, the same arrangement as Cl⁻, but 19 protons pulling on them, so K⁺ is smaller than Cl⁻. Whether K⁺ is smaller than neutral Cl requires data rather than reasoning alone; the safe answer is Cl⁻ > Cl and Cl⁻ > K⁺, each justified by a change in electron count or nuclear charge.
Worked example 4 — placing an unknown from its properties. A hypothetical element is a soft solid that reacts violently with water to give hydrogen and a solution that turns indicator blue, conducts electricity, and forms only a 1+ ion. A single 1+ ion and violent reaction with water are the marks of an ns¹ configuration; softness, conduction and low ionization energy are metallic. The element belongs in group 1. Because it is more reactive than sodium, it should be placed below sodium, where the outer electron is farther out and more easily lost.
🧩Section 3 · DoPractice, demonstrate, and explain
Representation task: a trend map. On a blank outline of periods 1 to 3, draw and label four arrows: atomic radius increases down and to the left; first ionization energy increases up and to the right; electronegativity increases up and to the right; metallic character increases down and to the left. Beside each arrow, write one sentence in terms of energy level and effective nuclear charge explaining why it points that way. Then write the noble-gas configuration of every element in period 2 and shade the s-block and p-block.
Independent performance: conductor ranking and a placement argument. Carry out the continuity-tester investigation with at least six materials, recording three trials each. Success criteria: a table of results with a bright/dim/dark rating; a periodic table with each tested element marked, and the alloys, mixtures and compounds listed separately with their composition; a paragraph explaining the pattern of conductors using the words metal, nonmetal, metalloid and valence electrons; a note on one material whose result may be misleading and why. Finally, for three pairs chosen by your teacher (for example Li and K, O and F, Na and Al), state which atom is larger, which is more electronegative and which is more easily ionized, with a justification for each that names the level and the effective nuclear charge.
✅Section 4 · Check8-question lesson practice test
An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.
Problem 1
Explain why all the halogens form 1− ions and react in similar ways, using electron configurations.
Show worked solution
Every halogen has the valence configuration ns²np⁵: fluorine 2s²2p⁵, chlorine 3s²3p⁵, bromine 4s²4p⁵. Each is one electron short of a filled p sublevel, the noble-gas configuration. Gaining one electron gives the configuration of the next noble gas, so each forms a 1− ion and each reacts with metals by taking one electron. Chemical properties depend mainly on valence electrons, and the valence configuration repeats down the group, so the behavior repeats.
Problem 2
Across period 3 the atoms get smaller from sodium to chlorine even though each has more electrons than the last. Explain.
Show worked solution
Each step across the period adds one proton to the nucleus and one electron to the same outer level, level 3. Electrons in the same level shield each other poorly, so the added proton increases the effective nuclear charge felt by every outer electron. The outer level is pulled in more tightly, and the radius shrinks. Size grows only when a new level is started, which happens down a group, not across a period.
Problem 3
Define first ionization energy and predict whether it is higher for potassium or for sodium. Justify your answer.
Show worked solution
First ionization energy is the energy required to remove the most loosely held electron from a gaseous atom in its ground state. Sodium has the higher value. Potassium's outer electron is in level 4, farther from the nucleus and shielded by one more filled shell than sodium's level 3 electron, so it is held less tightly and removed with less energy. Ionization energy decreases down a group.
Problem 4
Use the shielding effect to explain the trend in atomic size down a group.
Show worked solution
Down a group each element has one more occupied energy level than the one above it. The inner filled levels lie between the nucleus and the outer electrons and cancel part of the nuclear attraction; this is shielding. Although the nucleus gains protons, the outer electron feels only a modestly larger effective charge while sitting in a level that is much farther out. The distance effect wins, so atomic radius increases down the group.
Problem 5
Compare the size of a sodium ion, Na⁺, with a sodium atom, and the size of a chloride ion with a chlorine atom. Explain both.
Show worked solution
Na⁺ is much smaller than Na because the atom loses its only level 3 electron, so the ion consists of the level 1 and 2 core alone, held by the same 11 protons. Cl⁻ is larger than Cl because an extra electron is added to level 3 while the nuclear charge stays 17; the increased repulsion among 8 outer electrons spreads the level out. Cations are smaller than their atoms; anions are larger.
Problem 6
Which is more electronegative, oxygen or sulfur, and which is more electronegative, oxygen or nitrogen? Justify each using atomic structure.
Show worked solution
Oxygen is more electronegative than sulfur: both are ns²np⁴, but oxygen's bonding electrons are in level 2, closer to the nucleus and less shielded, so the nucleus attracts shared electrons more strongly. Oxygen is also more electronegative than nitrogen: they are in the same period, and oxygen has one more proton acting on the same level, giving a larger effective charge. For reference, the common-scale values are oxygen 3.44, nitrogen 3.04 and sulfur 2.58; the question asks for the structural justification, not the numbers.
Problem 7
Chlorine is a gas at room temperature while iodine, in the same group, is a solid. Explain using what position on the table tells you and what it does not.
Show worked solution
Position tells you both are halogens with ns²np⁵ and both form diatomic molecules. State at room temperature, however, depends on the strength of attraction between molecules. Iodine molecules are much larger and have more electrons, so the attractions between them are stronger and enough energy to separate them is not available at room temperature; iodine stays a solid. Chlorine molecules are small and attract weakly, so chlorine is a gas. The trend follows from intermolecular attraction, which position influences but does not directly state.
Problem 8
A student says silicon must behave like a metal because it is shiny and is used in electronics. Judge the claim.
Show worked solution
Shininess and use in electronics are not enough. Silicon is a metalloid: it has four valence electrons, bonds by sharing in a giant covalent network, is brittle rather than malleable, and conducts electricity far more poorly than a metal unless it is deliberately treated. In its bonding it behaves as a nonmetal; its limited, controllable conductivity is what makes it useful. The claim should be revised to say silicon shows a mixture of metallic and nonmetallic properties and which dominate depends on the situation.