Grade 3 · English language artsAbout 90 minutes
English language artsGrade 3About 90 minutes

Read a procedure using main ideas, features and evidence

Suggested multi-session teaching plan.

Ohio learning standards this draft targets

ela-2017:RI.3.1ela-2017:RI.3.2ela-2017:RI.3.2aela-2017:RI.3.2bela-2017:RI.3.3ela-2017:RI.3.4ela-2017:RI.3.5ela-2017:RI.3.7ela-2017:RI.3.8ela-2026:RI.3.2ela-2026:RI.3.4

Read the standard text

ela-2017:RI.3.1 Ask and answer questions to demonstrate understanding of a text, referring explicitly to the text as the basis for the answers.

ela-2017:RI.3.2 Analyze informational text development.

ela-2017:RI.3.2a Determine the main idea of a text.

ela-2017:RI.3.2b Retell the key details and explain how they support the main idea.

ela-2017:RI.3.3 Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect.

ela-2017:RI.3.4 Determine the meaning of general academic and domain-specific words and phrases in a text relevant to a grade 3 topic or subject area.

ela-2017:RI.3.5 Use text features and search tools (e.g., key words, sidebars, hyperlinks) to locate information relevant to a given topic efficiently.

ela-2017:RI.3.7 Use information gained from illustrations (e.g., maps, photographs) and the words in a text to demonstrate understanding of the text (e.g., where, when, why, and how key events occur).

ela-2017:RI.3.8 Describe the relationships between the evidence and points an author uses throughout a text.

ela-2026:RI.3.2 Describe the development of an informational text.

ela-2026:RI.3.4 Determine the meaning of general academic or domain-specific words and phrases in an informational text.

Provisional targets. Clause-by-clause educational review is still pending.

Section 1 · LearnLearn the idea
A fictional model record keeps plant identifier, date, measurement unit and observation together. The numbers illustrate recording conventions, not a universal plant growth rate.A fictional model record keeps plant identifier, date, measurement unit and observation together. The numbers illustrate recording conventions, not a universal plant growth rate.Fictional observation record · Plant AMay 4012345Shoot: 2 cmMay 8012345Shoot: 4 cmSame starting point and centimeter scaleSample entries · not a universal growth rate
A fictional model record keeps plant identifier, date, measurement unit and observation together. The numbers illustrate recording conventions, not a universal plant growth rate.

Read the original informational text: Keeping a Seed Observation Record. An observation record helps a class describe how plants change over time. A useful record connects each statement with a particular plant, date and observed feature. Without labels, two drawings made on different days can be hard to compare.

Prepare the record. Label each plant container with a letter or number. Use the same identifier on its record sheet. Write the date at the beginning of each observation. Keep a place for a drawing, a measurement and a brief note. These features allow another reader to match the record to the plant and the observation time.

Measure consistently. When measuring a shoot, decide on a starting point, such as the soil surface, and use it each time. Hold a suitable ruler beside the shoot without bending or damaging it. Record the unit with the number. A statement that a shoot measures five is incomplete if the reader cannot tell whether five means centimeters or another unit.

Sidebar: Choosing a ruler. Pick a ruler marked in centimeters. Find its zero mark before measuring, because on some rulers the zero is not at the very end.

Describe what is visible. A note might say that two leaves are visible or that a root has appeared. A prediction says what might happen later. Write predictions separately from observations so a reader does not mistake an expected event for something already seen. If no shoot is visible, record that rather than drawing the shoot you hope will appear tomorrow.

Compare records carefully. Line up entries for the same plant by date. Look for changes in length, visible parts or condition. Then check whether the measuring method changed. A different starting point can produce different numbers even if the shoot did not grow by that amount. Repeated measurements with a consistent method make the comparison more useful.

Keep questions open. If one plant grows differently from another, the record can show the difference. It may not explain its cause. Water, light, starting condition and other features may differ. A new investigation can test a possible explanation more carefully. A clear record supports questions as well as answers.

Find the main idea. This text explains how consistent, labeled observations make plant changes easier to document and compare. The main idea connects all sections. “Plants have leaves” is a detail related to one example, but it does not capture the whole text's purpose. Retell key details about identifiers, dates, units and separating observations from predictions to support the main idea. Each key detail supports it in its own way: matching identifiers show which plant an entry describes, dates show when it was observed, units tell what a number measures, and keeping predictions apart shows what was actually seen. Without any one of them, two entries would be harder to compare. The text develops its main idea step by step: it opens with the purpose of a record, and each headed section then adds one practice that makes records easier to compare.

Follow the order and the reasons. The guide is a procedure, so its sections come in a useful order: prepare the record, measure, describe what is visible, and after that compare the entries. In the guide, words such as when, each time and then signal time and sequence. Other sentences connect a cause with its effect: because a different starting point can produce different numbers, the guide says to use the same starting point each time; if a number has no unit, the reader cannot tell what it measures.

Text features help a reader find information. The heading “Measure consistently” leads to the ruler procedure. The heading “Describe what is visible” leads to the distinction between observations and predictions. In a digital version, searching for the keyword unit can help locate the measurement explanation. A search word is useful when it relates closely to the information needed. A sidebar is a short note set apart from the main text, often in a box at the side of a page. “Sidebar: Choosing a ruler” adds a related tip without interrupting the steps, so a reader who only needs help picking a ruler can go straight to it. In a digital text, a hyperlink is a word or phrase, usually underlined or shown in another color, that opens a related page or another part of the text when it is selected. If the word ruler under “Measure consistently” were a hyperlink to the sidebar, selecting it would take the reader there in one step. The guide is printed here without working hyperlinks, so practice using one in a teacher-approved digital text.

Academic and scientific words can be understood in context. Consistently means using the method in the same way across observations here. An identifier is the letter or number that links a plant to its record. The surrounding sentences explain each word's function, so use those clues before checking a dictionary for confirmation.

Section 2 · ModelWork through the examples

Worked evidence connection: The author recommends recording measurement units. The supporting explanation says a number such as five is incomplete when its unit is unknown. The example explains why the recommendation matters; it is not an unrelated decoration.

Worked visual connection: The model record labels plant A, dates and shoot lengths of two and four centimeters. It illustrates which information belongs together. The sample values are fictional, so they cannot establish how fast all beans grow. The diagram supports the text's recording procedure while the words explain the limits of a comparison.

Section 3 · DoPractice, demonstrate, and explain

Guided reading: Find the section that answers a measurement question and explain why its heading helped. Write one question of your own about the guide and point to the sentence that answers it. Identify the procedure's sequence and a cause-and-effect connection, such as an inconsistent starting point causing misleading comparisons. Retell the main idea with several relevant details rather than copying every sentence.

Independent evidence: Answer a question with a direct textual detail, explain a vocabulary word using context and connect the model record with the written directions. Perform a short observation using the guide and separate what was seen from what was predicted. State one question the record alone cannot answer.

Section 4 · Check8-question lesson practice test

An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.

Problem 1

What is the main idea of the guide?

Show worked solution

Consistent, labeled observations make plant changes easier to record and compare.

Problem 2

Why label both the container and record with the same identifier?

Show worked solution

So another reader can match the entry to the particular plant.

Problem 3

Which heading and which sidebar help a reader find information about a ruler, and what would a hyperlink add in a digital version?

Show worked solution

The heading “Measure consistently” leads to the ruler procedure, and the sidebar “Choosing a ruler” gives a short related tip set apart from the steps. A hyperlink, such as a linked word ruler, would open the related part in one step.

Problem 4

What does consistently mean in this text?

Show worked solution

Using the measurement method in the same way across observations, such as keeping the starting point fixed.

Problem 5

What evidence supports the advice to include units?

Show worked solution

The example explains that a measurement of five is unclear unless readers know whether it means centimeters or another unit.

Problem 6

Does a difference between two plant records by itself prove its cause?

Show worked solution

No. Conditions or methods may differ. Another investigation may be needed to test an explanation.

Problem 7

Retell three key details from the guide and explain how each one supports the main idea.

Show worked solution

Matching identifiers on the container and the record show which plant an entry describes. Dates show when each observation was made. Units tell what a number measures, such as centimeters. Each detail makes entries easier to match and compare, so together they support the main idea that consistent, labeled observations make plant changes easier to record and compare.

Problem 8

Why does the guide say to use the same starting point each time? Answer with a cause and its effect.

Show worked solution

Because a different starting point can produce different numbers even if the shoot did not grow by that amount, the entries could not be compared fairly. Keeping the same starting point avoids that effect.