Problem 1
What situation opens the model?
Show worked solution
A classroom display has six drawings but only five label cards, including a missing label for the narrator and Sam’s drawing.
ela-2017:W.3.3ela-2017:W.3.3aela-2017:W.3.3bela-2017:W.3.3cela-2017:W.3.3d
ela-2017:W.3.3 Write narratives to develop real or imagined experiences or events using effective technique, descriptive details, and clear event sequences.
ela-2017:W.3.3a Establish a situation and introduce a narrator and/or characters; organize an event sequence that unfolds naturally.
ela-2017:W.3.3b Use dialogue and descriptions of actions, thoughts, and feelings to develop experiences and events or show the response of characters to situations.
ela-2017:W.3.3c Use temporal words and phrases to signal event order.
ela-2017:W.3.3d Provide a sense of closure.
Learning goal: Write a real or imagined narrative with a clear situation, connected events, character responses and a sense of closure. A narrative tells an experience unfolding through time. It needs more than a list of actions: readers should understand what matters to the characters and how one event leads to another.
Read the original model: The Last Card. I carried the stack of display cards into our classroom with both hands. We were setting up a collection of leaf drawings before the afternoon visitors arrived. At the table, I counted six drawings but only five cards. The missing card belonged to the drawing I had made with Sam.
“I checked the box,” Sam said. He tipped it toward me so I could see the empty bottom. My fingers tightened around the stack. I wanted to blame the box, the crowded shelf, or anyone except myself. Then I remembered using one card to test a marker beside the sink.
After we searched the shelf, I walked to the sink. The card was there, with a dark line across its middle. “I used this one for testing,” I admitted. Sam looked at the line and then turned the card over. “This side is still blank.”
We wrote the label again, this time checking the drawing before spelling each word. A few minutes later, Sam placed the finished card beside our leaf. When the visitors entered, all six drawings had labels. I put the extra marker-test paper in a separate tray so the next group would know which pieces it could use.
Establish the situation. The opening introduces a first-person narrator, Sam, the classroom display and the missing-label problem. The writer does not need to describe every object in the room. Choose details that prepare the reader for the events, such as the count of drawings and cards.
Events unfold in a natural sequence. The missing card leads to checking the box, remembering the marker test, finding the card and rewriting the label. Words and phrases such as then, after and a few minutes later help readers follow time. The plot would be confusing if the card were rewritten before the reader learned it had been found.
Dialogue develops the experience. Sam's words explain that the box was checked and suggest using the blank side. The narrator's admission reveals a response to the problem. Dialogue should serve the scene; a long unrelated conversation about a different activity would slow the narrative without helping readers understand this event.
Actions, thoughts and feelings provide complementary details. Tightened fingers suggest tension. Wanting to blame other things reveals the narrator's thoughts. Walking to the sink and admitting the mistake move the story toward a solution. Instead of writing “I was upset” repeatedly, select details that show the particular response.
The ending resolves the immediate problem and shows a small consequence for future action. All six drawings have labels, and test paper receives a separate place. Closure does not require a grand moral sentence or a claim that every future problem disappears. It lets the reader understand how this experience has reached a stopping point.
Worked revision: A draft says, “The card was missing. I was nervous. We found it. It was fine.” Add the remembered marker test to explain where the card was, dialogue to show the admission, and the blank-side solution to connect discovery with the outcome. Details should fill an actual gap rather than merely lengthen the writing.
Worked sequencing: If an account begins with finding the marked card, the writer may need to explain why that card matters. For this straightforward narrative, establishing the display and missing label first gives readers the information they need. Other structures are possible, but they still must be understandable.
Guided writing: Choose a manageable event with a small change or problem. Plan the beginning situation, connected middle events and ending. Add dialogue or descriptive details where they reveal a response or move events forward. Read the draft to a partner and ask where they needed more information.
Independent evidence: Write an original narrative using a consistent narrator, clear sequence, temporal language and an ending related to the events. Revise one weakly connected transition and one general feeling statement. If writing about real events, distinguish remembered facts from imagined additions; if the story is fiction, identify it as imagined.
An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.
What situation opens the model?
A classroom display has six drawings but only five label cards, including a missing label for the narrator and Sam’s drawing.
What memory helps the narrator locate the card?
The narrator remembers using a card to test a marker beside the sink.
How does Sam’s dialogue contribute to the solution?
Sam notices that the reverse side remains blank and can be used for the label.
Give a detail showing the narrator’s tension or thoughts.
Examples include tightened fingers or wanting to blame the box and other things.
Name a phrase that signals time order.
Examples include then, after we searched the shelf, or a few minutes later.
How does the ending provide closure?
All drawings have labels, and the narrator separates marker-test paper to help the next group.