Grades 11–12 · English language artsAbout 150 minutes
English language artsGrades 11–12About 150 minutes
Write an informative or explanatory text that narrates a historical event or explains a scientific procedure, with a thorough thesis, a cumulative organization, well-chosen development, precise language and a significant conclusion
Several sessions across a history, science or technical-subject class: source study, modeled writing, drafting with peer response, revision and a completed independent piece.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2 Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures/ experiments, or technical processes.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2a Establish a clear and thorough thesis to present and explain information.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2b Introduce a topic and organize complex ideas, concepts, and information so that each new element builds on that which precedes it to create a unified whole; include formatting (e.g., headings), graphics (e.g., figures, tables), and multimedia when useful to aiding comprehension.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2c Develop the topic thoroughly by selecting the most significant and relevant facts, extended definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples appropriate to the audience's knowledge of the topic.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2d Use varied transitions and sentence structures to link the major sections of the text, create cohesion, and clarify the relationships among complex ideas and concepts.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2e Use precise language, domain-specific vocabulary and techniques such as metaphor, simile, and analogy to manage the complexity of the topic; convey a knowledgeable stance in a style that responds to the discipline and context as well as to the expertise of likely readers.
ela-2017:WHST.11-12.2f Provide a concluding statement or section that follows from and supports the information or explanation provided (e.g., articulating implications or the significance of the topic).
Provisional targets. Clause-by-clause educational review is still pending.
📘Section 1 · LearnLearn the idea
The five headed sections of the model explanatory text, each building on the previous one. Numbers: g about 9.8 m/s squared; release angle at most 10 degrees; 20 oscillations timed; 3 trials; slope 4.023 square seconds per meter giving g = 9.81 m/s squared; g ranges from about 9.78 at the equator to about 9.83 at the poles.
Learning goal: Write informative/explanatory texts, including the narration of historical events, scientific procedures or experiments, or technical processes: establish a clear and thorough thesis to present and explain information; introduce a topic and organize complex ideas, concepts and information so that each new element builds on that which precedes it to create a unified whole, including formatting such as headings, graphics such as figures and tables, and multimedia when useful; develop the topic thoroughly with the most significant and relevant facts, extended definitions, concrete details, quotations or examples appropriate to the audience's knowledge; use varied transitions and sentence structures to link major sections, create cohesion and clarify relationships among complex ideas; use precise language, domain-specific vocabulary and techniques such as metaphor, simile and analogy to manage complexity, conveying a knowledgeable stance that responds to the discipline and the expertise of likely readers; and provide a conclusion that follows from and supports the explanation, for example by articulating implications or the significance of the topic.
Informative is not argumentative. An argument asks the reader to accept a claim that could be disputed. An informative or explanatory text aims to make the reader understand something: how a process works, what happened and in what order, what a concept means. It still has a thesis, but the thesis states what will be explained and the key idea that unifies it, not a position to defend. "The pendulum method measures g by turning a relationship between length and period into a straight-line graph" is an explanatory thesis. In history, the narration of events is explanatory when it tells what happened in order, with dates and causes as the sources establish them, and marks what is uncertain.
Building so that each element prepares the next. Complex information must be sequenced so that each new element builds on what precedes it. For a scientific procedure the logic is usually: what is being measured and why; the concept the method depends on; the equipment; the steps in order, each with its reason; how the raw data become a result; how to judge the result. A reader who meets "plot T² against L" before learning what T is has been asked to use a term not yet built. Headings mark the sections; a table can hold data that would clog a paragraph; a figure such as a graph shows a relationship at a glance. Multimedia, such as a short video of a correct release, is useful when motion or timing is hard to describe in words.
Developing the topic for the audience. The most significant and relevant facts are the ones the reader needs to understand the process, not everything you know. An extended definition goes beyond a one-line gloss: it states the term's meaning, what it includes and excludes, and gives an example and a non-example. Quotations, concrete details and examples should be matched to the audience's knowledge: a text for students new to physics defines period and oscillation; a text for a physics teacher does not.
Precise language and figurative techniques. Domain-specific vocabulary (amplitude, oscillation, slope, uncertainty) is precise; everyday substitutes ("how far it goes," "wiggle") are not. Metaphor, simile and analogy manage complexity when they map the unfamiliar onto the familiar, and they must be accurate in the respect that matters. Saying that a pendulum "is like a playground swing" is fair, because both are pivoted masses whose period depends on length; saying that "gravity pulls harder on heavy bobs so they swing faster" is a false analogy dressed as explanation.
A knowledgeable stance and style. Writers in science often use the passive or impersonal voice for procedures ("the bob was released"), which keeps attention on the method, though many journals now prefer the active voice, including "we"; follow the convention of the course or publication and keep it consistent. They state measurements with units and describe uncertainty. Historians narrate in the past tense, date events precisely and attribute interpretations. Matching these conventions signals a knowledgeable stance.
A complete model explanatory text (science).
Measuring Gravity with a Pendulum
What is measured. Near Earth's surface, a falling object gains speed at a nearly constant rate called the acceleration due to gravity, g, about 9.8 meters per second per second. A pendulum measures g without timing a fall, which is too fast to time accurately with a hand-held stopwatch; instead, it measures how long a swing takes. This text explains how the pendulum method turns the relationship between a pendulum's length and its period into a straight-line graph whose slope gives g.
The key idea: period. The period of a pendulum is the time for one complete oscillation: the bob moves from one side to the other and back to where it started, moving in the same direction. A single sweep from one side to the other is only half a period. For a small, dense bob on a light string, swinging through a small angle, the period T depends on only two things: the length L from the pivot to the center of the bob, and g. The relationship is T = 2π√(L/g). Like a metronome whose weight is slid higher to slow the beat, a longer pendulum swings more slowly.
The procedure. A stand is clamped to the bench, and the length is measured to the nearest millimeter. The bob is pulled aside no more than 10° and released without a push. After two swings, 20 oscillations are timed, so that the error in starting and stopping the watch is shared among 20 periods. Three trials are made at each of four lengths.
From data to a result. Squaring the relationship gives T² = (4π²/g)L. When T² is plotted against L, the points fall on a straight line whose slope equals 4π²/g. The table shows one set of hypothetical class results (T is shown to three decimal places; each T² is calculated from the unrounded period).
L (m)
T (s)
T² (s²)
0.300
1.099
1.209
0.500
1.419
2.013
0.700
1.678
2.816
0.900
1.903
3.623
The slope between the first and last points is (3.623 − 1.209) ÷ 0.600 = 4.023 s²/m, so g = 39.478 ÷ 4.023 = 9.81 m/s².
Why it matters. The method shows how a careful procedure turns an everyday motion into a precise physical constant. Because the value of g varies slightly from place to place, from about 9.78 m/s² at the equator to about 9.83 m/s² at the poles, precise measurements of it are more than a classroom exercise.
A misconception. Students often think an informative text should contain every fact they found. Selection is the skill: a fact belongs only if the reader needs it to understand the topic.
✏️Section 2 · ModelWork through the examples
Worked extended definition: Term: amplitude. Meaning: the greatest angle, or distance, the bob moves from its resting position. Includes: the angle at release when the bob is let go without a push. Excludes: the length of the string, and the full width of the swing from one side to the other, which is twice the amplitude. Example: released at 8° from vertical, amplitude 8°. Non-example: a bob swinging 16° from one extreme to the other has an amplitude of 8°, not 16°. Why it matters here: the formula T = 2π√(L/g) holds only for small amplitudes, which is why the procedure limits the release angle to 10°.
Worked narration of historical events (informative, history): Thesis: "In the autumn of 1893 the Lusk Glass Company cut its workforce in stages, as falling orders, a bank failure and a wage dispute unfolded over six months." Narrative: "Orders peaked at $22,100 in April and fell each month to $8,200 in September. On 3 August the company's bank suspended payment. On 15 August the company proposed a 15 percent cut in the wage list; the union refused, and on 1 September men who would not sign were locked out. On 30 September the second furnace was shut. Whether the company intended to end the union list is disputed by the sources." The narration is in chronological order, dated, uses transitions of time, and marks the disputed point without arguing it. (Benton Ferry and the company are invented for this unit.)
Worked transitions and sentence variety: Draft: "The bob is released. It swings. Then you time it. Then you do it again. Then you square it." Revised: "Once the bob has been released and has made two swings, 20 oscillations are timed. Because a single timing includes the observer's reaction error, three trials are made at each length. Only after all four lengths are complete are the periods squared and graphed." Changes: varied openings (a time clause, a causal clause, an inverted "Only after..."), impersonal voice, a common convention for a procedure, and transitions that show time and cause.
🧩Section 3 · DoPractice, demonstrate, and explain
Plan and outline (representation): Choose a procedure, experiment, technical process or historical event from your coursework. Write a thesis that states what you will explain and the key idea that unifies it. Outline four to six sections with headings, arranged so each builds on the previous one. Mark where a table, figure or short video would help and describe it. Write one extended definition and one accurate analogy, noting in what respect the analogy holds.
Independent performance: Write an informative or explanatory text of 600 to 900 words. Success criteria: (1) a clear and thorough thesis that presents the information to be explained; (2) sections organized so each new element builds on the one before, with headings and at least one table or figure; (3) the most significant and relevant facts, one extended definition, concrete details and at least one quotation or example suited to a reader new to the topic; (4) varied transitions and sentence structures that clarify relationships between sections; (5) precise domain vocabulary and at least one accurate metaphor, simile or analogy; (6) the conventions of the discipline (units, stated uncertainty and one consistent voice for a procedure; past tense, dates and attribution for history); (7) a conclusion that states the implications or significance of the topic.
✅Section 4 · Check8-question lesson practice test
An adult may read the prompts aloud. Answer independently with words, objects, drawings or a demonstration before opening the answer guide. Award 1 point for a correct result or claim and 1 point for a matching explanation or demonstration; where a question asks only for a result (a corrected sentence, a spelling, a count), a fully correct result earns both points, and the answer guide shows what a complete response contains. Record prompting separately. The total (two points per question) is local practice feedback, not an Ohio proficiency level.
Problem 1
How does the thesis of an informative text differ from the thesis of an argument? Give an example of each on the same topic.
Show worked solution
An informative thesis states what will be explained and the idea that unifies it; an argument's thesis states a position that could be disputed. Informative: 'The pendulum method measures g by turning the relationship between length and period into a straight-line graph.' Argument: 'The pendulum method is a better way for a school to measure g than timing a falling ball.'
Problem 2
Explain why the model text defines 'period' before describing the procedure.
Show worked solution
Each new element must build on what precedes it. The procedure times oscillations and the analysis squares the period; a reader who did not yet know what a period is, or that one oscillation is there and back, could not follow either. Defining it first prepares everything that follows.
Problem 3
Write an extended definition of 'oscillation' suitable for a reader new to physics.
Show worked solution
An oscillation is one complete back-and-forth cycle of a repeating motion. For a pendulum it begins when the bob passes a point, continues to one side, returns through the start to the other side, and ends when the bob passes the starting point again moving in the same direction. It includes both halves of the motion; it excludes a single sweep from one side to the other, which is only half an oscillation. Example: a bob that passes the lowest point moving right, swings right, back left, and passes the lowest point moving right again has completed one oscillation.
Problem 4
The model compares a pendulum to a metronome whose weight is slid higher to slow the beat. In what respect is the analogy accurate, and where would it mislead?
Show worked solution
It is accurate in the respect that matters: in both, moving the effective mass farther from the pivot lengthens the time of each swing. It would mislead if a reader concluded that a metronome's mechanism is identical: a metronome has a counterweight below the pivot and is driven by a spring, so its exact timing depends on more than one length.
Problem 5
Where does the model use a table, and why is a table better than a sentence there?
Show worked solution
It uses a table for the lengths, periods and squared periods. Twelve numbers with units in a sentence would be hard to compare; in a table the reader can see directly how T and T squared grow with L and check the slope calculation.
Problem 6
Identify two conventions of scientific writing the model follows, and two conventions a history narration would follow instead.
Show worked solution
Science: impersonal or passive voice for the procedure, a common though not universal convention ('the bob is pulled aside... and released'), and units with every measurement (m, s, m/s squared). History narration: past tense with precise dates ('On 15 August the company proposed...'), and attribution of interpretations to their sources, including marking where sources disagree.
Problem 7
Quote one sentence in the model text that links two of its sections, and one sentence in the worked revision that shows cause or sequence. For each, name the transition or sentence structure used and the relationship between ideas that it makes clear.
Show worked solution
Linking sections: 'Squaring the relationship gives T² = (4π²/g)L' opens the section 'From data to a result' by picking up 'the relationship' stated in 'The key idea: period', so the reader meets the straight-line graph as a consequence of T = 2π√(L/g) and not as a new topic; its subject, 'Squaring the relationship', names an operation on the formula given a section earlier. Another sentence that links sections is the thesis, 'This text explains how the pendulum method turns the relationship between a pendulum's length and its period into a straight-line graph whose slope gives g', which announces the sections to come. Cause: 'Because a single timing includes the observer's reaction error, three trials are made at each length' puts the reason in an opening subordinate clause, so the step and its justification arrive together. Sequence: 'Only after all four lengths are complete are the periods squared and graphed' uses inverted word order to stress that one step must wait for another. A complete answer quotes the words, names the structure and states the relationship: consequence, cause, contrast or sequence.
Problem 8
What does the model's conclusion add, and why does it follow from the explanation rather than start a new topic?
Show worked solution
It articulates significance: a careful procedure turns an everyday motion into a precise constant, and because g varies from about 9.78 to about 9.83 m/s squared between the equator and the poles, measuring it precisely has real uses. It follows from the explanation because it builds on the 9.81 m/s squared result and the precision the procedure achieved.